Vine Street Café Menu

Vine Street Café on Shelter Island offers a sophisticated New American menu that beautifully marries classic flavors with inventive twists. Standouts like the crispy duck confit and miso-glazed salmon showcase the kitchen’s skillful balance of texture and depth. The tuna tacos and spicy tuna tartare tacos, bursting with fresh, vibrant flavors, offer a unique take on casual favorites. Delicate dishes such as the scallops and half dozen oysters highlight the café’s focus on quality seafood, perfectly suited to the coastal setting. The homemade fries provide a comforting, crispy counterpoint that diners rave about. For dessert, indulgent options like sticky toffee pudding and classic profiteroles cap the meal with rich, satisfying notes. Complementing the menu is an impressive selection of whiskies and brandies, offering a refined finish to the dining experience. Vine Street Café remains a standout destination for those seeking both innovation and tradition on Shelter Island.